Les Miserables is a musical that carries a lot of weight for me. I read an abridgement of the story first when I was in Mrs. Hill’s grade 8 class, I have seen two professional stage versions of it, read a much longer abridgement of it twice and directed the musical twice. For me it sits at the pinnacle of what musical theatre can be. It has a story which really matters, music that grabs your soul and twists hard and it is all brought together in a package that is wonderfully exhausting and completely worthwhile. So the prospect of seeing it in a movie is something that I was, mostly looking forward to, but also somewhat afraid of. This music, this story is very important to me and I did not want to see it sullied.
I loved Anne Hathaway. Her performance carried a fragile grace that is so painful to watch as it is broken. “I Dreamed a Dream” is not so much sung as torn from her by the tigers in the night. Jackman could have paid attention to her example of acting into the song without loosing the melodic thread. Many people have commented on the excessive use of close ups, I did not find this to be distracting for me. The musical is a large grand thing but it is very much the story of individuals and being able to see their faces as they sing in a way that it is impossible to when you are watching it live was engaging for me.
There were some things that disappointed me. Hugh Jackman tries to act into the music so much that we sometimes loose the melodic thread. There are some expositional elements added to the songs to help the uninitiated through the story and I didn’t mind that until Gavroche goes on a narrative streak in the second verse of “Do You Hear the People Sing?” the was just pure exposition. The song that they added in during Cossette and Valjean’s ride to paris did not fit with the musical themes or the tone of the musical; it was very out of place. Javert did not bristle with the righteous intensity that his character demands and then he pins his medal on Gavroche’s dead body, I felt that that was completely out of place. Aside from Jackman’s interpretation these are relatively small things and I really enjoyed the experienced of seeing this musical on the big screen.